Princeton Council Debates Future of Historic Firehouse Amid Affordable Housing Plans
- Meeting Overview:
At the recent Princeton Council meeting, discussions revolved around the future of the historic Chester Street Firehouse, amidst plans to repurpose the site for affordable housing. This proposal has stirred local emotions, particularly from Bill Shields, a resident and long-time member of the Princeton Fire Company Number One, who argued against the plan. Shields highlighted the firehouse’s role as a community cornerstone, rich with artifacts dating back to the 1800s. He urged the council to find a balance between preserving the town’s history and addressing the need for affordable housing, emphasizing that the building holds irreplaceable community value. Shields stated, “We cannot allow this building to be a lost of time and his invaluable history be buried beneath the weight of modern development,” advocating for thoughtful planning and community engagement in deciding the firehouse’s fate.
Following the public commentary, the Council moved to review several resolutions and applications, focusing on maintaining the historic character of Princeton while accommodating necessary updates. One key discussion involved the installation of snow guards on a historic building at 6 to 10 Nassau Street. The Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) assessed the proposal, which aimed to protect pedestrians from falling snow and ice while preserving the building’s historic integrity. The snow guards, made from lead-coated copper, were designed to blend with the existing slate roof over time. After some deliberation, the council unanimously approved the motion, recognizing the necessity and appropriateness of the safety measure.
The meeting also addressed a setback variance request for a property at six Eland Place in the Jugtown historic district. The property’s construction had unintentionally encroached on the front yard setback, prompting the HPC to offer advisory input to the zoning board. The applicant required a two-foot variance for compliance, and discussions centered on the minimal visual impact of the encroachment. The council ultimately supported the variance, emphasizing the need to preserve existing trees and maintain the area’s visual integrity.
Additionally, the council considered a setback variance related to the ongoing construction of a garage at the same property. The plans initially submitted did not accurately reflect the as-built condition, leading to a recommendation that the applicant return with updated plans. There was consensus on the importance of ensuring compliance with zoning regulations while allowing construction to progress.
The council also reviewed an application from Princeton University trustees for updates to properties at Edwards Place in the Mercer Hill District. This included replacing windows, doors, and siding. The council moved forward with the application despite a lack of quorum for another application concerning 344 Nassau Street, which was rescheduled for a future meeting.
In other discussions, Kip Cherry provided an update on efforts to install state markers for Princeton’s 250th anniversary. He noted that two markers had been submitted for approval, emphasizing their historical significance, particularly related to Captain Leslie’s burial after the Battle of Princeton. The council was encouraged to visit the proposed marker locations to appreciate their relevance.
The meeting concluded with acknowledgments of the importance of adaptive reuse in preserving Princeton’s architectural heritage. An update was shared about a tour of the new Triumph restaurant, which had repurposed the former post office site. Further discussions touched on integrating affordable housing within historic districts, recognizing the challenges and complexities involved in balancing preservation with modern housing needs.
Mark Freda
City Council Officials:
, Mia Sacks, Council, Leticia Fraga, Councilmember, David Cohen, Councilmember, Eve Niedergang, Councilmember, Michelle Pirone Lambros, Councilmember, Leighton Newlin, Councilmember
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
11/17/2025
-
Recording Published:
11/17/2025
-
Duration:
74 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Mercer County
-
Towns:
Princeton
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/04/2025
- 12/05/2025
- 46 Minutes
- 12/04/2025
- 12/05/2025
- 210 Minutes
- 12/04/2025
- 12/04/2025
- 21 Minutes