Red Bank Zoning Board Approves Liquor Store Use Variance Amid Community Concerns

The Red Bank Zoning Board meeting on February 20, 2025, resulted in the approval of a use variance for a proposed liquor store on Shrewsbury Avenue, a decision that stirred considerable debate among board members and the community. Despite concerns about the store’s size and its potential impact on the neighborhood’s character, the board granted the variance, contingent on further site plan approvals and compliance with several conditions.

21:45The most contentious discussion centered around the proposed relocation and expansion of an existing liquor store into a larger facility. This proposal required a use variance due to its location in a neighborhood business zone. The applicant, represented by Mr. Edward W. O’Neal Jr., argued that the new store would remain a neighborhood establishment, despite its increased size. He emphasized the strategic location and the building’s potential to serve as a functional business after being vacant for several years.

Board members expressed divergent views on the proposal. Some were apprehensive about introducing a “Superstore” liquor store, fearing it could disrupt the residential area’s character and exacerbate existing litter issues. One member pointed out that the new store would double the size of the current operation, arguing that it could detract from the community’s essence. Concerns were also raised about the proximity of community services related to substance misuse, adding weight to the argument against a larger liquor store in the area.

42:46Conversely, other board members defended the proposal, highlighting the need for revitalizing the long-vacant property and supporting local businesses. They argued that the store would not equate to larger liquor establishments found in other towns and underscored the importance of maintaining neighborhood enterprises to prevent larger retailers from overwhelming the local market.

21:45The meeting also delved into the operational details of the proposed liquor store. The store was slated to operate from 9:00 AM to 10:00 PM daily, employing a minimal staff. Plans for waste management were discussed, with the majority of waste consisting of recyclable cardboard. The board scrutinized parking arrangements, emphasizing the need for compliance with safety and accessibility standards. The proposed site plan included the addition of parking spaces and a trash enclosure, with a focus on maintaining traffic flow and ensuring delivery efficiency.

1:06:05The aesthetic impact of the store’s exterior and signage was another focal point. Board members expressed strong opposition to large advertisements and neon signs that could detract from the building’s refined appearance. Suggestions for frosted windows and restrictions on window signage were discussed to maintain a more appealing aesthetic.

1:27:14Although public attendance at the meeting was sparse, the board noted that previous community suggestions had influenced the applicant’s plans, particularly concerning landscaping and site issues.

As the discussion progressed, the board contemplated various conditions that could be attached to the use variance approval. These included compliance with operational regulations, restrictions on outside storage, and a monitoring policy for loitering, which was deemed essential for maintaining community standards.

Ultimately, the board approved the use variance with five affirmative votes, enabling the liquor store to move forward with the proposed site plan, pending further approvals.

Note: This meeting summary was generated by AI, which can occasionally misspell names, misattribute actions, and state inaccuracies. This summary is intended to be a starting point and you should review the meeting record linked above before acting on anything you read. If we got something wrong, let us know. We’re working every day to improve our process in pursuit of universal local government transparency.

Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:

Trending meetings
across the country: