Sayreville School Board Faces Community Backlash Over Policy 5756
- Meeting Overview:
The December 16th meeting of the Sayreville Board of Education was marked by community engagement, primarily centered around the contentious policy 5756, which many residents believe undermines parental rights. The board also acknowledged student and staff achievements, discussed financial audits, and introduced new student programs and infrastructure updates.
The primary focus of the meeting was the public response to policy 5756. This policy has been a point of contention, with numerous residents voicing their concerns during the public comment period. Jessica Vant, a community member, highlighted the opposition from over 4,700 residents who supported a parental rights platform. She accused outside influences, specifically naming Michael Gotsman from the New Jersey Public Education Coalition, of swaying local board decisions and organizing protests against the board meetings. Vant expressed apprehension about legislative proposals in New Jersey that could potentially diminish parental rights and affect student welfare, including those related to mental health treatment consent and school property leases.
Mary Savinski, another resident, criticized policy 5756 for allegedly alienating parents from discussions about their children’s identity and emotional health. She called for policies that respect parental rights while providing necessary support to students. Joe Ryan, identifying as both a parent and grandparent, echoed these concerns, arguing that excluding parents from their children’s education and well-being is detrimental.
The public participation segment continued with other residents, including Mickey Fischer, who inquired about policies for teachers regarding transgender students, and Kim Lley, a former teacher, who emphasized the importance of transparency in school policies. She criticized any policy that promotes secrecy between schools and parents. Victoria Pepe raised questions about the balance between student privacy and parental responsibilities, expressing concern about the potential exclusion of parents from notable decisions about their child’s well-being. A co-parent in the audience also voiced worries about policy 5756 disrupting communication in dual-household families.
The board did not provide a direct response to the public’s concerns during the meeting, leaving many residents eager for further discussion and clarification in future sessions.
Aside from the policy discussions, the meeting celebrated various student achievements. The girls’ cross country team received recognition for winning the Greater Middlesex Conference Gold Division championship. The coach praised the team’s resilience, especially noting the challenges faced with a small group of athletes. Angela Lri broke a school record by running a 5K in under 19 minutes, an accomplishment that was met with enthusiastic applause.
The meeting also addressed financial matters, with Mrs. Pabon reporting on the finance and infrastructure committee’s review of the district’s audit findings. The district was commended for its financial management, maintaining a stable capital reserve while other districts faced cuts. Despite this, some challenges remained, including the need to spend COVID-allocated food service funds and adjust climate control in newly installed systems. There was mention of new electronic signs being installed for the middle schools.
Personnel and student program updates were also on the agenda. The personnel committee reported ongoing recruitment efforts and a forthcoming job fair. The board approved a dual certification pathways grant to enhance educational opportunities and discussed new middle school elective offerings for the 2026-2027 school year. Proposed changes included increasing student choice and aligning courses with educational standards. Results from the New Jersey Graduation Proficiency Assessment showed 40% of eligible seniors passed the English assessment, while only 16% succeeded in math, prompting further efforts to support students.
Superintendent Dr. Richard Labbe announced donations received by the district, including contributions from the New York Giants and the New Jersey Educators Association, recognizing Rosa Morgan as Educator of the Week. A community member also donated $1,000 to the Woodrow Wilson School for playground equipment. Dr. Labbe addressed ongoing projects, such as the parking lot expansion at Eisenhower School and necessary kitchen adjustments at Arlo School.
As the meeting concluded, the board acknowledged the forthcoming retirements of Lynn Taylor, a respected physical education teacher and athletic director, and Michael Pnano, the lead custodian. Both were recognized for their years of service to the district.
Dr. Richard Labbe
School Board Officials:
Lucy Bloom, Jeffrey Smith, Christopher Callahan, Carrie Chudkowski, Eloy Fernandez, Katya Hernandez, Leidy Maldonado, Alison Napolitano, Eileen Pabon, Erin Hill (Custodian of Records), Busch Law Group, LLC (Attorney), Suplee, Clooney & Company (Auditor), Nicole Petrone (Treasurer of School Funds)
-
Meeting Type:
School Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
12/16/2025
-
Recording Published:
12/16/2025
-
Duration:
82 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Highly Noteworthy
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Middlesex County
-
Towns:
Sayreville
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/17/2025
- 12/17/2025
- 243 Minutes
- 12/17/2025
- 12/18/2025
- 124 Minutes
- 12/17/2025
- 12/17/2025
- 10 Minutes