05:43The focal point of the meeting was the board’s response to Karthik’s comments on social media, which some community members perceived as disrespectful towards Islamic practices. Board President Laura Hernandez addressed the issue, stating that Karthik’s posts violated policy 0169.02 concerning board member use of social networks. Hernandez announced that Karthik was removed from her committees on education and policy as a consequence.

28:56During public comments, the atmosphere was charged with passionate speeches defending Karthik’s right to free expression. Community member Hmon Pandya questioned the board’s rationale for Karthik’s committee removal, emphasizing the constitutional right to free speech. Pandya, along with others, argued that the board’s actions infringed on Karthik’s rights.

21:37Desikhan Narasiman criticized the backlash Karthik faced, describing it as a “witch hunt” that unfairly targeted her family and employer. He condemned the board for not allowing Karthik to clarify her statements, asserting that the board’s silence tolerated aggressive behavior. Narasiman’s remarks were echoed by various speakers, including a South Brunswick High School senior who questioned whether the school was fostering an inclusive environment or punishing dissenting opinions.

03:00The controversy drew further attention when a speaker pointed out the board’s inconsistency in applying its social media policy. Another speaker criticized the board for not enforcing the same policy when another board member allegedly made incendiary comments about a political party. Ajay Sha, a community member, called for transparency, urging the board to disclose all social media posts by its members on contentious issues.

01:15:53Rajan, a supporter of Karthik, defended her comments as expressions of personal ethical beliefs, protected by the First Amendment. He emphasized the necessity of open dialogue in a democracy and condemned attempts to misrepresent Karthik’s words as hateful. Other speakers echoed this defense, arguing that Karthik’s service on the board should not be overshadowed by her personal social media activity.

01:21:55The meeting also featured opposition to Karthik’s comments. Omar Oscar, co-president of the South Brunswick High School Muslim Student Association, expressed outrage, calling for Karthik’s removal and a public apology. Oscar highlighted the impact of her statements on Muslim students and emphasized the need for the board to take action to restore community trust.

01:25:58Amidst the intense exchanges, a student named Bosker called for de-escalation, emphasizing the importance of civil discourse and understanding among differing beliefs. Bosker acknowledged the need for constructive discussions, reminding attendees that “freedom of speech is not freedom from consequence.”

01:29:55The board announced that the next meeting would occur on June 19, 2025, where the discussion is likely to continue.