St. Pete Beach City Commission Debates Merry Pier Bait Shack’s Future Amid Community Concerns
- Meeting Overview:
During the recent St. Pete Beach City Commission meeting, the fate of the Mary Pier Bait Shack took center stage, with commissioners unanimously approving a motion to rebuild the damaged structure while exploring cost-effective design revisions. The bait shack, not designated as historic, was appraised at $210,000, with rebuilding costs estimated slightly higher. With FEMA’s review ongoing and insurance contributions pending, the commission weighed options, from demolition to selective rebuilding. Community discussions highlighted the bait shack’s significance, with one commissioner emphasizing its role as a community focal point. Concerns about the dock’s condition and potential hurricane threats underscored the urgency of a decision. Public comments revealed strong community ties to the pier, with suggestions to establish a self-insurance fund from rental income for future repairs.
Another topic was the potential relocation of a historic house to Pass-a-Grille Park. The city staff presented the challenges of moving a wood-framed house dating back to around 1925. The city’s budget earmarked $177,000 for rebuilding a shuffleboard area, with quotes for demolition and relocation highlighting financial constraints. Community input was sought to determine the house’s final use, and concerns about the project’s feasibility arose due to unclear relocation sites, funding gaps, and the structure’s age. The house’s historical significance was emphasized, and a deadline was set by the homeowner for vacating the property by January 1st, adding urgency to the discussion.
The commission also addressed the condition of the Merry Pier and its surrounding dock, with recent hurricane damage raising safety concerns. While the dock was deemed largely intact, the building’s structural integrity remained a concern. Financial discussions revealed funds allocated for permits and improvements, with the commission stressing the pier’s importance as a community hub.
In matters of zoning and land development, the commission debated complexities surrounding building heights and the applicability of existing regulations. Concerns were raised about the interpretation of building heights and density allowances, with a call for clarity and uniformity in applying codes. The potential for revisions to the land development code was discussed, considering the limitations imposed by Senate Bill 180. The need for a review of zoning regulations and their historical application was emphasized, with a proposal for a work session to facilitate understanding before the next Board of Adjustments meeting.
The commission also tackled issues within the permit and building departments, focusing on improving efficiency and customer service. Acknowledging process problems rather than staff issues, suggestions were made for enhancing permit processing, such as implementing same-day permits for low-risk applications and establishing a single point of contact for applicants. The idea of streamlining the review process across departments was proposed to prevent confusion and delays. The commission recognized the need for ongoing evaluations of the permitting process to meet community expectations and maintain compliance with building codes and regulations.
Additionally, the meeting addressed the “Live Local Act” property tax exemption, with the commission opting out to retain more ad valorem taxes for local use. The discussion acknowledged a delay in the Shimberg report, which was necessary to confirm eligibility for the exemption.
The commission also considered a petition for converting a dog beach to allow off-leash access, with discussions on potential safety and community impacts. While recognizing mixed feelings about the proposal, the commission emphasized the importance of community input and resource stewardship.
Adrian Petrila
City Council Officials:
Karen Marriott (Commissioner, District 1), Lisa Robinson (Commissioner, District 2), Betty Rzewnicki (Commissioner, District 3), Joe Moholland (Commissioner, District 4)
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
12/16/2025
-
Recording Published:
12/16/2025
-
Duration:
234 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Florida
-
County:
Pinellas County
-
Towns:
St. Pete Beach
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/17/2025
- 12/17/2025
- 94 Minutes
- 12/16/2025
- 12/17/2025
- 55 Minutes
- 12/16/2025
- 12/16/2025
- 106 Minutes