One of a notable topics was the board’s unanimous decision to grant a certificate of appropriateness for the Seahorse restaurant located on Pass-a-Grille Way. The Seahorse, already a locally designated historic resource, sought restoration to its pre-damage condition. The applicant’s proposal included maintaining key original elements, such as kitchen doors and exterior walls, using materials that matched the original design. Specifically, the kitchen doors were to be replaced with galvanized steel, and the TRU decking was to be restored. The use of plank cedar siding, consistent with the original structure, was confirmed, and existing rooftop mechanical equipment would remain at the same elevation. Awnings would retain their original color scheme.

The board engaged in a dialouge about the restoration process, emphasizing the importance of matching original materials and styles. Questions regarding the specifics of the materials were addressed, with staff confirming that all proposed changes adhered to the historic nature of the property. After resolving these inquiries, a motion was made and seconded, leading to a favorable vote. Board members expressed satisfaction with the restoration plans.

Another noteworthy topic was the board’s discussion of an emergency ordinance aimed at streamlining the FEMA variance process for locally designated structures. This ordinance, recommended by the board at a previous meeting, would particularly facilitate situations where damage was limited to interior elements or involved one-for-one restorations. The board expressed hope that the commission would approve the ordinance, which could expedite matters for property owners seeking FEMA variances.

The board also addressed a request for a certificate of appropriateness for the demolition of a single-family residence on Passer Girl Way. The request, submitted by Ben Freeman on behalf of the Judith H Preston Trust, was accompanied by photographs taken post-storm. Staff recommended against imposing a stay on the demolition, prompting a discussion among board members about the unfortunate loss of the historic structure. Despite expressing regret over the demolition, the board recognized the challenges in preserving the home. A motion to approve the demolition certificate without a 30-day delay was made and seconded, resulting in a unanimous vote.

In addition to demolition concerns, the board emphasized that any new construction proposals following demolitions would be subject to review within the historic district’s geographic boundaries. This assertion reinforced the board’s authority in overseeing future construction activities.

The board also considered local historic designation cases, such as the approval of a two-unit residence at 102 20th Avenue and the residence on Casablanca Avenue, owned by Daniel Elliot Nixon. Nixon presented the property as a contributing resource within the Don CeSar neighborhood, as established in a recent historic resources survey. The board reviewed a photograph from the 2024 survey, which highlighted the structure’s historical significance, and unanimously approved the designation.

Similarly, the board approved the local historic designation of a single-family residence on Casablanca Avenue, owned by Vincent and Rosaria Tmania. Vincent Tmania shared personal anecdotes about the neighborhood’s history and emphasized the importance of maintaining its character against potential corporate encroachments. The board acknowledged his sentiments, and the motion to approve the designation passed unanimously.

There was a brief discussion about the Doctor Hotel, with inquiries about its status and the possibility of historical designation. Although no current information was available, the conversation highlighted the building’s historical significance.