Stillwater School Board Faces Community Divide Over Identity Harm Protocols
- Meeting Overview:
At a recent Stillwater Area School Board meeting, the proposed identity harm protocols became a focal point of discussion, highlighting community division on how bullying related to identity should be addressed. The protocols aim to address bullying based on race, gender, religion, and other aspects of identity, with opinions sharply split between those advocating for their implementation and those questioning their necessity and effectiveness.
18:56The discourse was marked by passionate public comments. Some community members expressed strong support for the identity harm protocols. One speaker cited a report indicating that a portion of students, particularly those identifying as LGBTQ+, experience bullying based on identity. Supporters argued that the protocols would equip educators with the necessary tools to address and prevent such incidents, aligning with the district’s mission of fostering an accepting and secure learning atmosphere.
0:00Conversely, others criticized the protocols, questioning their potential to divide rather than unify students. Critics argued that addressing bullying should not be categorized by identity, asserting that all students deserve equal treatment regardless of their backgrounds. Concerns were also raised about the advisory committee’s composition, with some feeling it lacked diverse community representation and leaned too heavily towards school employees.
1:14:44The meeting also delved into the operational aspects of implementing these protocols. The proposed measures include a structured response to identity harm, emphasizing safety, denouncement of harmful acts, and restorative practices. The importance of early communication with families and thorough fact-finding in incidents was highlighted as essential components of the process. This approach aims to foster accountability and support among students and staff.
1:47:52In conjunction with addressing identity harm, the school board discussed the broader context of bullying prevention within the district. There was an emphasis on engaging both students and parents in ongoing dialogue to ensure their voices are heard and incorporated into strategic planning.
0:00The meeting also celebrated the service of outgoing board member Beverly Petrie, who was attending her last meeting. She was acknowledged for her substantial contributions to the district, including her role in hiring the current superintendent and leading critical initiatives. Petrie’s departure was marked by gratitude for her leadership and the stability she brought to the board.
38:50Additionally, the board addressed a update on the district’s literacy curriculum. With the recent enactment of the Read Act, requiring evidence-based literacy instruction, the board discussed plans to adopt new curricula that align with these standards. The transition involves evaluating current programs and piloting new ones, with a focus on professional development for teachers to ensure effective implementation.
Financial implications of the new literacy curricula were also a concern, as projected costs exceed the state’s funding allocation. The board acknowledged the need for strategic funding solutions to support the curriculum transition, emphasizing a staggered approach to implementation to manage the financial and training burdens on staff.
1:47:52The meeting concluded with the approval of bids for the Oakland Middle School addition and remodel, totaling over $24 million. The project includes the construction of a new gymnasium and additional classrooms, set to be completed in phases by fall 2026.
Dr. Michael Funk
School Board Officials:
Katie Hockert, Pete Kelzenberg, Chris Lauer, Beverly Petrie, Annie Porbeni, Alison Sherman, Andrew Thelander
-
Meeting Type:
School Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
12/17/2024
-
Recording Published:
12/21/2024
-
Duration:
126 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Highly Noteworthy
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Minnesota
-
County:
Washington County
-
Towns:
Afton, Bayport, Baytown Township, Denmark Township, Grant, Hugo, Lake Elmo, Lake St. Croix Beach, Lakeland, Lakeland Shores, Marine On St. Croix, May Township, Oak Park Heights, Oakdale, Scandia, St. Mary's Point, Stillwater, Stillwater Township, West Lakeland Township, Woodbury
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 05/15/2025
- 05/16/2025
- 38 Minutes
- 05/15/2025
- 05/16/2025
- 81 Minutes
- 05/15/2025
- 05/15/2025
- 47 Minutes