A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the approval of a certificate of appropriateness for the demolition of a property on Pass-a-Grille Way. Owners Victor Tonis and Wendy Hopwood sought to demolish their storm-damaged home, which had been flooded with 39 inches of water. The board was presented with photographs showing extensive damage, and staff recommended swift approval of the demolition due to the property’s lack of architectural uniqueness and significant damage. Tonis described the difficulties faced in deciding whether to rebuild or elevate the home, ultimately opting for a new elevated construction that would comply with FEMA regulations. The board unanimously approved the demolition, recognizing the owners’ intent to maintain the neighborhood’s character while ensuring future resilience against storms.

In a similar vein, the board reviewed and approved the demolition of a commercial structure on Pass-a-Grille Way, which included a two-story retail building and a one-story outbuilding. Despite the building’s historical significance, staff concluded that the damage rendered remediation unreasonable, and the board agreed to proceed with demolition to allow potential redevelopment. Again, the decision was unanimous.

In another notable decision, the board unanimously approved a local historic designation for properties at 3215 and East Deason Avenue. Representing the applicants, Gil Martinez detailed the multifamily duplex structure’s significance, built in 1949 in a Mediterranean Revival style by Thomas Row, the developer of the iconic Don CeSar Hotel. The board acknowledged the building’s contribution to the Don CeSar Place neighborhood’s character, leading to a unanimous approval for its historic designation.

The board also addressed the restoration of the Thomas Row House on Casablanca Avenue, which required a certificate of appropriateness for replacing an outdoor screen patio that had been severely damaged by a hurricane. Historic consultants highlighted the house’s mission-style architecture and its eligibility for National Register listing. The proposed restoration was supported by staff, aligning with the city’s Land Development Code and the house’s historic character. The board approved the restoration unanimously.

Furthermore, the meeting featured discussions on amendments to the Pass-a-Grille Historic Overlay District and the CRD 8th Avenue District ordinances. Proposed changes included requiring new developments with public alley access to provide driveway access solely from that alley and adjustments to pool placement regulations. The introduction of a design guidebook was emphasized, with a timeline for completion in two to three months. Board members expressed a sense of urgency to expedite the process, given ongoing demolitions and changes in the area.

The board also tackled the issue of building height regulations, particularly concerning floodproofing and compliance with FEMA standards. Concerns were raised about ambiguous language in the current regulations, which might allow constructions exceeding intended height limits. The board sought recommendations for clearer language to tighten existing regulations and prevent broad interpretations that could lead to height excesses.

Beyond preservation and demolition, the board discussed community projects, such as the Hurley Park playground proposal. The acting Recreation director outlined the project’s history and fundraising efforts, with a budget of $140,000 allocated for installing a new playground. The board noted the importance of public-private partnerships in revitalizing local recreational spaces, reflecting ongoing community engagement.

In closing, the board considered updates on historic plaque production and local business status, noting the trend of businesses struggling to reopen post-storm. Discussion also extended to the Mary Pier and the shuffleboard court, both impacted by a storm. Members proposed involving the private sector in reconstruction efforts, recognizing the pier’s significance as a historic community symbol.