Stuart City Commission Denies Land Use Change Amid Community Concerns
- Meeting Overview:
In a recent Stuart City Commission meeting, the most significant event was the decision to deny a request to change the future land use designation of a property from low-density residential to commercial. This decision came after community members from the Willoughby Glenn neighborhood expressed strong opposition to the change, citing concerns about the potential impact on their community, including increased traffic and the exacerbation of existing homelessness and addiction issues.
The meeting opened with a discussion about water quality and the resolution to petition the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for new water quality criteria for cyanotoxins. It was deemed necessary to establish more standards for these harmful algae toxins, which pose a risk to drinking water and recreational activities. The resolution, after some debate and clarification on its language, was approved by the Commission.
The Commission also addressed the establishment of oyster gardens along the St. Lucie River. This initiative, presented in partnership with the Coastal Conservation Association of Florida, aims to improve water quality and provide habitat for marine life. Oysters act as natural filter feeders, and the proposed vertical oyster gardens along the downtown Riverwalk are expected to enhance marine ecosystems and potentially scale up for future projects. Despite concerns about potential liabilities and the need for permits if the gardens require removal, the commission approved the establishment of the oyster gardens.
Another focus of the meeting was the comprehensive plan future land use map amendment for a property located on Southeast Indian Street. The amendment sought to change the land use from multifamily residential to commercial. The applicant argued that the change would correct previous inconsistencies in land use designations and align with planning principles. Staff recommended approval of the amendment, highlighting the development potential of the property as an assisted living and memory care facility, without significant impact on public facilities or property values in the surrounding area. Despite some public opposition concerned with increased traffic and a preference for residential development in response to a shortage of family housing, the commission approved the future land land-use map amendment without public opposition.
Regarding the denied land use change, the discussion was punctuated by the residents’ arguments that developing the property for residential use would better serve the community due to a documented need for family housing. The concerns about traffic congestion were echoed by at least one commissioner, who pointed out the already problematic congestion at the intersection near the proposed site. The community’s concerns about the impact of the land use change on issues such as homelessness were also taken into account by the commissioners.
In addition to these main topics, the Commission addressed several administrative matters. They acknowledged the efforts of city staff and community members, including Mr. Jim Rean, for their contributions to the city. Commissioner Collins responded to a public comment by affirming the commission’s active engagement with the public between meetings. Commissioner McDonald, while thanking those involved in organizing the Memorial Day parade, raised concerns about the heat’s impact on attendees.
The City Manager requested the withdrawal of an agenda item due to a technicality, and a resident expressed dissatisfaction with certain projects approved by elected officials during the public comment period. However, these discussions did not dominate the meeting as the above-mentioned issues did.
Becky Bruner
City Council Officials:
Campbell Rich, Eula Clarke, Christopher Collins, Troy McDonald
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
05/28/2024
-
Recording Published:
05/28/2024
-
Duration:
86 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Florida
-
County:
Martin County
-
Towns:
Stuart
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/18/2025
- 12/18/2025
- 84 Minutes
- 12/18/2025
- 12/18/2025
- 78 Minutes
- 12/18/2025
- 12/18/2025
- 155 Minutes