Tamara Phillips voiced significant allegations concerning the conduct of Brian W. Child, the artistic director of the Barn Theater. Phillips accused Child of unprofessional behaviors, including cyber and sexual harassment, and highlighted safety concerns regarding rehearsal environments. She reported that several cast members had resigned or been dismissed due to these issues, which included handling loaded firearms during rehearsals. Phillips noted that the principal actress had left after the theater board failed to address her concerns about Child’s behavior, raising additional issues of misrepresentation of qualifications and a conflict of interest linked to Child’s family’s financial contributions to the theater. The mayor acknowledged the gravity of the accusations but noted the absence of Child to provide a counter-narrative. The city attorney suggested that some allegations might warrant police investigation, while others could require a civil lawsuit approach.

Following Phillips, William Raj raised further allegations of misconduct among city officials, including accusations of fraud and constitutional violations. Raj urged a thorough investigation into these claims, emphasizing the commission’s duty to address the situation comprehensively and calling for transparency and accountability.

Amidst these serious allegations, the commission also tackled the issue of introducing a new business, the Spice and Tea Exchange, to the downtown area. The proposal sparked debate around maintaining the district’s unique character versus embracing new economic opportunities. Concerns were raised about the potential impact of franchise businesses on downtown’s identity. Some commissioners suggested implementing a cap on the number of formula-based businesses allowed, fearing the introduction of franchises could undermine the area’s distinctiveness.

The property owner, Max Ducharm, and the business operators, Glenn and Kimberly Gordon, argued in favor of the Spice and Tea Exchange. Ducharm emphasized that the store would operate unobtrusively, citing its small size, adherence to urban design codes, and lack of visible corporate advertising. He argued that the business would attract foot traffic and enhance the downtown experience without paving the way for larger corporate franchises. Ducharm noted that the presence of the Spice and Tea Exchange would not prevent larger corporations from applying in the future but emphasized that rejecting the business could lead to less desirable tenants.

Public comments revealed a mix of support and concern. Lillian Peterson, a downtown business owner, advocated for the Tea and Spice Exchange, highlighting its potential to offer unique experiences and draw visitors. In contrast, Gail Goldie voiced apprehension about setting a precedent for future franchises and the risk of homogenizing downtown’s character. Clay Sharer argued that the store differed from typical franchises. Bailey Cape, representing another local business, supported the proposal, emphasizing the shop’s potential to complement existing businesses.

The commission ultimately made a motion to approve the resolution for the Tea and Spice Exchange, following city staff recommendations, despite the lingering concerns about maintaining downtown Stuart’s unique charm.

In other meeting discussions, the commission recognized November 2025 as Hospice and Palliative Care Month, and service awards were presented to city staff members for their dedication. Chief plant operator James Allen was honored posthumously for his contributions to the water reclamation facility. Additionally, a proclamation celebrated the centennial of the First Baptist Church, acknowledging its cultural and spiritual significance in the community.