Summit City Planning Board Tackles Noise Ordinance Amid Construction Concerns
- Meeting Overview:
During the February 24, 2025, meeting of the Summit City Planning Board, members addressed community concerns about noise from construction at the BMS site, prompting a review of the noise ordinance. Additionally, the board approved a 90-day extension for Park View Terrace’s subdivision deed filing and discussed the 2024 Development Review and Redevelopment Ordinance (DRRO) revisions. The board also explored the implications of the state’s new advisory document on cross acceptance and examined the board’s potential role in municipal capital projects.
The board’s discussion on the noise ordinance was sparked by ongoing complaints from residents about disturbances caused by construction activities at the BMS site. The need for a review of the noise ordinance was highlighted, with one member expressing hope that this issue would catalyze broader regulatory scrutiny. The suggestion to establish a subcommittee to review and revise development regulations and zoning ordinances was made, with volunteers stepping forward to participate.
A specific concern was raised regarding the maximum height of rooftop lighting fixtures, set at 10 feet above the roof deck. This standard was debated in the context of its potential impact on noise and light pollution. An expert argued that a height of 10 feet was reasonable, citing that similar fixtures are typically installed at 12 to 14 feet to ensure adequate light spread. The board discussed the necessity of balancing visibility from surrounding areas with development scope.
The conversation about noise extended to the police department’s lack of equipment to measure decibel levels, hindering effective enforcement of noise complaints. An anecdote was shared regarding the installation of bafflers around air conditioning units at the BMS site, illustrating that straightforward solutions could address resident grievances. The board also considered referencing the noise ordinance in the rooftop lighting section to prevent conflicts with existing regulations. They acknowledged the county’s stricter standards and the potential for ordinance improvement to enhance enforcement and community satisfaction.
The board then addressed Park View Terrace’s request for a 90-day extension to file a minor subdivision deed. Represented by their attorney, the applicants cited delays in obtaining necessary documents, such as a storm sewer agreement. The board evaluated the request under the Municipal Land Use Law, which permits extensions if applicants demonstrate diligent pursuit of approvals. Following a motion and roll call vote, the extension was approved.
Attention shifted to the approval of the 2024 DRRO revisions, which received unanimous support in a roll call vote. The board acknowledged only minor adjustments from the previous year’s ordinance but expressed enthusiasm for further enhancements in 2025.
In a discussion on cross acceptance, the board reacted to a new state advisory document that diminishes the influence of the State Development and Redevelopment Plan on local zoning. The document’s advisory nature led members to question its purpose, especially given its original intent to guide affordable housing processes. Concerns were raised about aligning local development goals with the state’s new guidelines, highlighting the potential need for a refined method to calculate affordable housing obligations.
The conversation also explored the planning board’s involvement in municipal capital projects. The outdated county Master Plan, last reviewed in 1998, was identified as a concern, and the board discussed the potential for increased collaboration in capital improvement planning. While some members noted the rarity of planning boards engaging in these programs, it was suggested that the board’s review could ensure consistency across projects and enhance decision-making.
As the meeting drew to a close, the board prepared for a closed session to discuss the housing element and fair share plan, driven by ongoing litigation related to affordable housing. It was emphasized that while the session would be closed, the overall process would remain open to public input, with public hearings integral to the plan’s development.
Elizabeth Fagan
Planning Board Officials:
Ryan Felmet (Mayor or designee), Matthew DiLauri (Municipal Official), Delia Hamlet (Common Council member), Steven Spurr, John Zucker, Chair, Patrice Magee, Jennifer Balson Alvarez, Vice Chair, Rick Bell (Alternate I), Susan Bowen (Alternate II), Paul Formichelli, Paul Stern, L. Knight (Interim Zoning Officer), Stephanie Soulios (Planning Board Secretary)
-
Meeting Type:
Planning Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
02/24/2025
-
Recording Published:
02/24/2025
-
Duration:
89 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Union County
-
Towns:
Summit
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/12/2025
- 12/12/2025
- 64 Minutes
- 12/10/2025
- 12/11/2025
- 77 Minutes
- 12/10/2025
- 12/11/2025
- 18 Minutes