Summit City Planning Board Tackles Subdivision Issues and Committee Appointments Amid Reorganization
- Meeting Overview:
In the January 22nd, 2024 meeting of the Summit City Planning Board, a comprehensive reorganization took place with the swearing-in of five new members and the election of Steven Spurr as the chair and Jennifer Balson Alvarez as vice chair. The board also addressed a range of topics, including the potential subdivision of properties, the responsibilities and operations of the board, and the appointment of members to various committees.
At the forefront of the meeting, discussions centered on a contentious subdivision application for a property on Summit Avenue. The board grappled with concerns regarding the practicality of constructing a conforming structure on the lot due to the need for multiple variances, particularly those related to side yard and building coverage percentages. Additionally, the potential impact of substantial sanitary sewer encroachments on the neighborhood’s character was debated. Board members were divided, with some expressing hesitance to support the application without a more detailed development plan that could address the limitations and potential detriments to adjacent properties. The applicant, in response to the feedback received, showed willingness to postpone the application to a later date in order to provide a more comprehensive proposal that would address board and community concerns.
The meeting also focused on changes within the board’s structure and governance. Five new board members were welcomed. Steven Spurr took the helm as chair, with Jennifer Balson Alvarez appointed as vice chair, and Stephanie Soulios was instated as board secretary. The board unanimously agreed to hire professionals for 2024, including an attorney, engineers, and a planner, and approved committee appointments across various areas such as environmental, affordable housing, park line steering, shade tree advisory, and historic preservation committees. Notably, Matthew DiLauri expressed a desire to serve on the affordable housing committee, while Steve Spurr was nominated for the Mount Laurel committee, tasked with addressing issues related to affordable housing in the community.
Moreover, the board tackled critical procedural matters, including the rules for conducting hearings, the importance of providing public comment opportunities, and the enforcement of board resolutions and conditions. Members debated the language used in the rules, particularly concerning the removal of a board member and the enforceability of conditions, seeking clarity and potential revisions to ensure proper governance.
The complexities of the subdivision process were on full display as the board deliberated on applications for minor subdivisions at two Park View Terrace and Linden Road. The applicants, Michael and Susan Ballow, sought approval for their plans to create two new lots from an existing one. The board scrutinized ongoing work on the properties in question, the preservation of trees, drainage conditions, and the resolution of easements. The public voiced concerns about neighborhood average lot sizes, stormwater management, and the implications of granting variances on future development.
In another case, Christina Amonson raised issues about the slope and drainage of 23 Linden Road, emphasizing the potential impact on the neighborhood’s water flow due to the property’s proximity to the second Wang Mountain. Patty Proctor, a resident, conveyed anxieties about the possibility of the new lot remaining vacant and the precedent it could set. The board assured that the city would address maintenance concerns and investigate any lack of upkeep regarding neighborhood properties.
The meeting concluded with a discussion on potentially expanding a committee to cover the entire city and the board’s deliberation on the conditions of approval for proposed subdivisions. The board considered imposing restrictions, such as the requirement for any variances requested for the lots to be reviewed by the planning board, and debated the city’s role in enforcing stormwater management for future developments. The resolution to adopt new rules and regulations for the board was passed after a roll call vote.
Elizabeth Fagan
Planning Board Officials:
Ryan Felmet, Matthew DiLauri, Delia Hamlet, Steven Spurr, John Zucker, Patrice Magee, Jennifer Balson Alvarez, Rick Bell, Susan Bowen, Paul Formichelli, Paul Stern, Christa Anderson (Zoning Officer), Stephanie Soulios (Planning Board Secretary)
-
Meeting Type:
Planning Board
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
01/22/2024
-
Recording Published:
-
Duration:
257 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Union County
-
Towns:
Summit
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 12/16/2025
- 12/17/2025
- 37 Minutes
- 12/16/2025
- 12/16/2025
- 157 Minutes
- 12/16/2025
- 12/16/2025
- 123 Minutes