Village Manager’s Resignation Sparks Controversy at Islamorada Council Meeting
- Meeting Overview:
The Islamorada Village Council meeting was marked by attention to the resignation of Village Manager Rob Cole, with discussions surrounding the process and transparency of his departure dominating the session. Public comments underscored community frustration over the perceived lack of openness and clarity regarding the decision-making process, as well as concerns about adherence to the Florida Sunshine Law.
02:31:25The resignation of Rob Cole as Village Manager was a focal point of public discourse, with numerous residents expressing dissatisfaction with how the situation had been handled. Allegations of backroom dealings and a lack of transparency were prevalent, with some community members suggesting that Cole’s resignation was influenced by ulterior motives. The process by which the severance package was proposed and accepted drew scrutiny, as did the council’s communication with the public. A motion to accept Cole’s resignation was passed with a 4-1 vote, despite strong public opposition.
02:12:11One speaker criticized the council for conducting decisions “in the dark,” while another expressed concern that the decision to replace Cole may have been the result of a conspiracy involving previous managers. Concerns about potential violations of the Sunshine Law were raised by a council member, who questioned whether the decision-making process had been properly conducted in compliance with open government requirements.
01:18:23Public comments highlighted the community’s appreciation for Cole’s contributions during his tenure, with many expressing regret over his departure. There were calls for an investigation into the circumstances surrounding the resignation, as well as a request for greater transparency in future personnel decisions.
38:40In addition to the discussions about Cole’s resignation, the council addressed other topics, including a proposed vessel exclusion zone at Sunset Drive Beach. The proposal, which had garnered support from local homeowners, was debated in terms of its potential impact on local fishing practices and environmental considerations.
02:54:46The council also considered a proposal for a comprehensive compensation and classification study for village employees. The study aims to address existing discrepancies in pay scales and job descriptions, with a focus on ensuring competitive compensation for emergency services personnel. Public comments emphasized the need for urgent action to adjust salaries for paramedics and other critical staff, reflecting concerns about retention and recruitment in a highly competitive job market.
01:16:36The council faced criticism for perceived prioritization of development interests over community needs, with calls for more inclusive governance and a focus on preserving the local environment.
The session concluded with a unanimous decision to proceed with the compensation study, as well as acknowledgment of the need to fill the village manager vacancy promptly. The council expressed gratitude for the outgoing manager’s service and highlighted the importance of a timely transition to ensure continuity in village operations.
Sharon Mahoney
City Council Officials:
Don Horton (Vice Mayor), Joseph “Buddy” Pinder III, Deb Gillis, Steve Friedman
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
01/07/2025
-
Recording Published:
01/13/2025
-
Duration:
197 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Noteworthy
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
Florida
-
County:
Monroe County
-
Towns:
Islamorada
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 08/07/2025
- 08/07/2025
- 354 Minutes
- 08/07/2025
- 08/07/2025
- 314 Minutes
- 08/07/2025
- 08/07/2025
- 157 Minutes