A significant portion of the meeting focused on the petition for a conditional use permit to construct a new 300-foot wireless communication tower in Udica Township. This proposal, presented by Cloud One Services, aimed to enhance network coverage in the area, with AT&T as the initial anchor tenant. Residents raised concerns about the structural integrity of the proposed tower and its potential impact on nearby properties. Discussions revealed that engineering assessments assured the tower would collapse within a 160-foot radius in the event of failure. Furthermore, the planning staff confirmed that no significant cultural resources would be affected by the tower’s construction.

A representative clarified that while the tower could accommodate at least four carriers, securing additional tenants depended on various factors, including the needs of emergency responders and technical requirements. The commission emphasized the importance of ensuring that the tower’s construction would not disrupt local farming practices, with assurances given that existing agricultural activities could continue unhindered.

The commission also considered a broader telecommunications infrastructure plan aimed at improving coverage across Winona County. Representatives from the telecommunications company outlined plans for multiple new sites, including potential locations near St. Charles, Wilson Township, and Dakota. They acknowledged the RF challenges in Winona County and the existing subpar coverage from major carriers like Verizon and T-Mobile. The representative highlighted ongoing environmental assessments, particularly regarding the impact on migratory birds and compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act.

The lighting of the towers was another concern, with newer LED technology designed to minimize obtrusiveness. The representative confirmed efforts to reduce visibility impacts on local residences and the environment. Additionally, the discussion addressed the necessity of reliable communication infrastructure in emergencies, referencing past service failures during events like the 2007 Stockton flood.

In response to public concerns, the commission explored the aesthetic integration of towers into the landscape, with suggestions for camouflaging them as natural features to mitigate visual impact. The topic of tower ownership and sharing among carriers was also discussed, noting that Verizon allows collocation on its facilities, which has evolved since the late 1990s when public apprehension about cell towers was prevalent.

A motion to recommend approval of the tower installations, contingent on all conditions and findings of fact, was passed unanimously. The commission acknowledged the need for a balanced approach to tower development, considering both highway users and rural communities.

Another agenda item was the proposal by Jake and Mary Yoder to establish a new schoolhouse in St. Charles Township, within an agricultural resource conservation zoning district. The Yoders presented their case, highlighting the need for local educational resources as existing schoolhouses were at capacity. The proposed site included a variance from the required feedlot setback and careful consideration of the playground’s location relative to neighboring properties.

Community members voiced mixed feedback during the public hearing. Concerns were raised about potential traffic hazards on County Road 35, with calls for improved safety measures. A resident expressed opposition to the school’s location due to traffic issues, while another suggested the school could reduce the number of children walking along the road, potentially enhancing safety.

The commission discussed the necessity for appropriate signage and collaboration with the Winona County highway department to address road safety concerns. Ultimately, the commission voted to approve the schoolhouse plans, with conditions to ensure safety and minimal disruption to the community.