Oakland Borough Residents Voice Concerns Over New Garbage Contract and Collection Changes
- Meeting Overview:
During the recent Oakland Borough Council meeting, the primary focus was on the contentious changes to garbage collection services and the associated new contract with Pompton Lakes. The shift in service has led to a wave of concern among residents about increased costs, service quality, and a lack of transparency from the council. Many residents expressed dissatisfaction with the contract’s terms, particularly the mandated change in garbage can sizes and the perceived disconnect between promised savings and the actual financial impact on households.
The council meeting opened with a portion devoted to discussing the borough’s new garbage collection service, which began on July 3rd. The borough administrator explained that the transition to Pompton Lakes was primarily driven by a need to manage increasing waste collection costs, which had risen by 290% over the past ten years. He highlighted that the previous vendor was the only bidder, leading the borough to seek alternatives that would save approximately $1.4 million over the contract’s duration, equating to about $250 in savings per household.
Residents voiced concerns about the lack of communication regarding these changes. Mike Guanino criticized the council for a perceived lack of transparency, arguing that residents were misled into believing that no changes would occur. He pointed out that the new system was implemented without adequate notice or consultation, leading to confusion and dissatisfaction. Guanino also highlighted concerns about fee escalators in the contract and the potential financial implications for residents.
The debate over garbage can sizes was a prominent issue, with the shift from 32-gallon to 45-gallon cans causing frustration among residents. The new size requirement, which includes a weight limit of 60 pounds, was attributed to safety concerns for workers. Residents like Dean Trivani argued that the costs associated with purchasing new cans could negate any savings from the contract. Trivani calculated that if several households needed to buy new cans, the initial savings would be effectively nullified, stressing the financial burden this change imposes.
Another resident, Liz Caretta, raised concerns about the bear population in the area and questioned whether the changes in garbage collection would affect bear interactions. She emphasized the need for “bear-friendly conversations” with the Department of Environmental Protection to mitigate potential wildlife issues.
One council member apologized for any impatience displayed during the early days of the service change.
In addition to garbage collection issues, the meeting also addressed other topics. A new electric bike law is set to take effect on July 19th, with residents encouraged to check the borough’s website for details about bike registration. The council also discussed infrastructure concerns, specifically drainage improvements on Lakeshore Drive. A collapsed storm sewer pipe was identified as needing urgent replacement, with an estimated cost of $30,000 for the required work.
The council noted the completion of paving on the north side of town and the success of recent community events, such as Soccer Palooza, which attracted around 400 participants.
The council also addressed the need for an independent assessment of the Oakland Police Department. A proposed resolution to conduct the assessment aimed at improving the department’s operations was discussed. The resolution faced opposition, with some members arguing that it would be more beneficial after addressing current staffing issues. The lack of support led to the resolution not advancing, causing some council members to express disappointment over missed opportunities for good governance.
Additionally, the council deliberated on the potential redevelopment of the Burger King property, which remains stagnant due to expired extensions for the owner. Plans to invite the borough planner and affordable housing attorney to the August meeting were announced to explore redevelopment strategies.
Eric Kulmala
City Council Officials:
Steven Saliani (Council President), Carol Ann Rose (Councilwoman), John McCann (Councilman), Pat Pignatelli (Councilman), Kevin Slasinski (Councilman), Russell Talamini (Councilman)
-
Meeting Type:
City Council
-
Committee:
-
Meeting Date:
07/14/2026
-
Recording Published:
07/14/2026
-
Duration:
112 Minutes
-
Notability Score:
Routine
Receive debriefs about local meetings in your inbox weekly:
-
State:
New Jersey
-
County:
Bergen County
-
Towns:
Oakland
Recent Meetings Nearby:
- 07/23/2026
- 07/23/2026
- 14 Minutes
- 07/22/2026
- 362 Minutes
- 07/22/2026
- 07/22/2026
- 12 Minutes